Legalise Freedom

 

Posts Tagged ‘ID cards’

March to ID cards costing the public quarter of a million pounds a day

Tuesday, November 17th, 2009

The roll out of the controversial identity cards has already cost the public millions of pounds and the bill is growing, figures show. The daily cost to the taxpayer for the expansion of the biometric documents is now six times the size it was just three years ago. Last month it emerged some 28 million people would have to sign up for an ID card in order to cover the cost of the scheme.

The Identity and Passport Service spent £42 million on developing both the ID cards and biometric passport programmes in the six months since March this year. That was equivalent of £229,508 every day – the highest amount of spending on the joint scheme so far. In 2008/09, a total of £81.5 million was spent – the equivalent of £223,288 a day. Between April 2003 and April 2006, a grand total of £41.1 million was spent – just £37,534 a day, although costs were always expected to rise as the programme expanded and began to roll out.

Both the Liberal Democrats and the Conservatives have pledged to scrap ID cards if they win power next year. Overall, the scheme is expected to cost £4.5 billion over ten year, money which the Lib Dems said they would spend on extra police instead.

Read article: http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/newstopics/politics/lawandorder/6563868/March-to-ID-cards-costing-the-public-quarter-of-a-million-pounds-a-day.html

Comment on this Article

The end of the ID register? Not unless you don’t need a passport

Friday, July 3rd, 2009

British citizens who apply for or renew their passport will be automatically registered on the national identity card database under regulations to be approved by MPs in the next few weeks.

The decision to press ahead with the main elements of the national identity card scheme follows a review by the home secretary, Alan Johnson, of the £4.9bn project. Although Johnson said the cards would not be compulsory, critics say the passport measures amount to an attempt to introduce the system by the backdoor.

Johnson said he had halted plans to introduce compulsory identity cards for airline pilots and 30,000 other “critical workers” at Manchester and London City airports this autumn in the face of threats of legal action. Longer term plans to extend compulsory ID cards to other transport industries, such as the railways, as a condition of employment have also been scrapped.

 040406id


But two batches of draft regulations to be approved by MPs tomorrow and next week are expected to include powers to make the passport a “designated document” under the national identity card scheme. This means that anyone applying for or renewing their passport from 2011 will have their details automatically added to the national identity databases.

The regulations also include powers to levy a fine of up to £1,000 on those who fail to tell the authorities of a change of address or amend other key personal details such as a change of name within three months.

Read article:

http://www.guardian.co.uk/politics/2009/jun/30/passport-details-id-card-database

Comment on this Article

The end of ID cards?

Wednesday, July 1st, 2009

British citizens will never be forced to carry ID cards, the Government announced today. Home Secretary Alan Johnson said that a trial scheme that was to force some airport staff to carry the controversial cards has been scrapped. The massive climbdown means that carrying an ID card will now never be made compulsory for members of the general public. The move signals the end of one of Labour’s most controversial policies, which has been championed by a succession of Home Secretaries, and threatens to further undermine the authority of the Prime Minister. And the retreat will be seized upon by Opposition parties and campaigners who have argued the £5billion scheme is unnecessary and excessively expensive.


Help prevent terrorism! If you've nothing to hide you've nothing to fear! Trust me.
Help prevent terrorism! If you’ve nothing to hide you’ve nothing to fear! Trust me.


Shadow home secretary Chris Grayling accused the Government of an ‘absurd fudge’ over the decision. Insisting that ID cards should be voluntary, Mr Johnson said: ‘Holding an identity card should be a personal choice for British citizens – just as it is now to obtain a passport.’ Previously, ministers said ID cards could become compulsory once 80 per cent of the population was covered.

Read article:

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1196561/Compulsory-ID-cards-scrapped-Government-performs-humiliating-U-turn.html

Comment on this Article

The cost of ID cards: £2,857 each

Wednesday, June 24th, 2009

ID cards could cost as much as £2,857 each based on the amount of money the government has already committed to the pilot project, politics.co.uk can exclusively reveal.

The figure dwarfs former home secretary Jacqui Smith’s claims that ID cards will cost individuals no more than £30 each, unless the government intends to heavily subsidise their production.

 bell512


A Freedom of Information request to the Home Office by politics.co.uk revealed the total money spent to date by the department to “design, build, test and operate the technology to support issue of the first ID cards” stands at £20 million over five years.

Meanwhile, the Home Office’s own annual report says it intends to issue ID cards to “7,000 British nationals” this year.

Taking the £20 million already spent on the development of ID cards and dividing this by the 7,000 people the Home Office expects to issue them to produces an individual cost per card of £2,857.

Read article:

http://www.politics.co.uk/news/legal-and-constitutional/the-cost-of-id-cards-2-857-each-$1305361.htm

Comment on this Article

So what we do when ID Cards 1.0 finally dies?

Wednesday, June 24th, 2009

UK Identity Card 1.0 is in deep trouble. It’s running late, and if the Conservative Party wins next year’s election it’ll be scrapped. Its original architect has changed his mind, and even some Cabinet members are starting to see it as a needless expense. But if we pull the plug, what then?

The cards may go away, but the issue won’t. Problems associated with identity, privacy and security will remain burning issues facing both the technology industry and wider society. But the irony is that the UK is well placed to develop a model identity framework for the 21st Century. Unlike many other countries, we don’t have the problems of any existing, legacy national identity scheme to encumber us. We have a clean slate. We could have got this right and shown the art of the possible.

 national-id-papers-please


All the more reason to be dispirited then with the current identity plan, which seems to be rooted in a 1960s view of computing, with everyone’s personal information stored in some monolithic central system and proposed identity cards that seem to be little more than plastic copies of the cardboard identity documents the UK population was forced to use during the second world war.

It is as if someone has dusted off a document for a state-centric identity scheme from another era, one before the digital, Internet, consumer-driven age. But I won’t dwell on this as the failings of the current scheme have been the topic of endless well-informed analysis and comment already.

Read article:

http://www.theregister.co.uk/2009/06/19/identity_two_dot_oh/  

Comment on this Article

The Big Question: Is the writing on the wall for the Government’s ID card scheme?

Wednesday, June 24th, 2009

Why are we asking this now?

The Government had been due to award a key contract as part of its grand biometric ID card scheme this autumn. Three companies – Thales, Fujitsu and IBM – were bidding for the right to develop the cards’ design and handle their production. But this week the Home Office admitted a decision might not be made until the second half of 2010. This is the second delay to have hit the Government’s ID card scheme. Under the original plans, the widespread roll-out of the cards would have taken place next year. Now it is not due until 2012.

Why the latest delay?

The Home Office argues that commercial and technical considerations are responsible. But it has been noted that the decision comes at a time when the future of the scheme has never looked more precarious. This week the shadow Home Secretary, Chris Grayling wrote to companies who might be involved in producing the cards to warn them that the scheme would be cancelled if the Conservatives win power at the next election; something the opinion polls suggest is increasingly likely.

Read article:

http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/the-big-question-is-the-writing-on-the-wall-for-the-governments-id-card-scheme-1708915.html

Comment on this Article

Stopping ID cards – companies bidding for contracts should remember that a change of government will mean an end to the scheme

Sunday, June 21st, 2009

The identity card scheme is gathering pace. Contracts are being let, cards are already being issued to some foreign nationals and the scheme to make airside personnel carry official ID cards at certain airports is under way. A month ago, the former home secretary, Jacqui Smith, announced plans for a city-wide voluntary pilot of ID cards in Manchester.

 untitled


Yet the underlying truth still remains, this is the wrong project at the wrong time. The wrong project because of the civil liberties issues it raises, and the very real doubts that it will make a difference in the battle against terrorism and organised crime. I have met virtually no one in the policing and security world who thinks ID cards are an essential part of what they need to do in the future.

Read article:

http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/libertycentral/2009/jun/17/identity-cards-conservatives-scrap

Comment on this Article

NO2ID - Stop ID cards and the database state